Flutter 3.16 UI Restoration Guide

Problem Statement

After upgrading to Flutter 3.16, apps may exhibit unexpected UI changes:

1. App bar: Loses shadows, gains translucent tint when scrolling
2. Background: Body shifts from pure white to tinted color
3. Buttons and spacing: Increased tap targets and padding
4. Material components: Dialogs/pickers adopt light purple tint (or theme color)

These changes result from Flutter 3.16 enabling Material 3 by default, which introduces updated design semantics, color schemes, and component behavior.

---

Primary Solution: Disable Material 3

Opt out by setting useMaterial3: false in your theme:

MaterialApp(
  theme: ThemeData(
    useMaterial3: false, // Reverts to Material 2 styling
    // Other theme properties...
  ),
);

Temporary Fix

useMaterial3 is a backward-compatibility flag that will eventually be deprecated. Migrate to Material 3 long-term using the official migration guide.

---

Component-Specific Fixes

For partial adoption of Material 3, adjust individual widgets:

App Bar Tint Removal

Set surfaceTintColor to Colors.white:

// Global theme override
ThemeData(
  appBarTheme: AppBarTheme(
    surfaceTintColor: Colors.white, // Disables tint effect
  ),
);

// Per-app bar override
AppBar(
  surfaceTintColor: Colors.white,
);

Restore Background Color

Set explicit scaffold/body colors:

ThemeData(
  scaffoldBackgroundColor: Colors.white, // Pure white background
  canvasColor: Colors.white, // Fixes dialog/overlay backgrounds
);

Control Dialog/Picker Appearance

Override transparency and backgrounds:

ThemeData(
  dialogBackgroundColor: Colors.white, // Solid background
  dialogTheme: DialogTheme(
    backgroundColor: Colors.white, 
    surfaceTintColor: Colors.transparent, // Remove tint
  ),
  bottomSheetTheme: BottomSheetThemeData(
    backgroundColor: Colors.white,
  ),
);

---

Material 2 vs. Material 3

Feature	Material 2	Material 3
App Bar	Shadowed, opaque	Tinted, translucent
Button Sizing	Compact forms	Larger touch targets
Color System	Primary/secondary accents	Expanded tonal palettes
Components	Skeuomorphic elevation	Flat planes with tint

Interactive Demo

Explore visual differences in this Material 2 vs Material 3 demo.

---

Migration Recommendations

1. Short-term: Use useMaterial3: false for critical UI recovery
2. Gradual migration: Override specific components using ThemeData properties
3. Full migration:
   • Update color schemes using ColorScheme.fromSeed
   • Test touch targets with new size guidelines
   • Verify component behavior in breaking changes log

---

Conclusion

Flutter 3.16's Material 3 defaults prioritize modern design trends and accessibility. While opting out provides immediate consistency for existing apps, leverage Flutter's theming system to incrementally adopt Material 3 standards. Target full migration before Material 2 support ends in future updates.